Popular skinner Kol, was asked by Microsoft to take down his Vista Windowblind and Visual Style.

MS claims that he was infringing on their copyrights, and he has complied, removing the skins from Wincustomize, Deviantart, and other sites.

With six more VIsta-style WB skins showing on Wincustomize https://www.wincustomize.com/Skins.aspx?LibID=1&view=1&sortby=4&sortdir=DESC&p=1&advanced=0&searchtxt=vista how does one skinner get targeted?

While I understand the need to protect copyrights and trademarks, I'd think M$ would chalk it up to "fan art" and be glad for the exposure.

During development for the Xbox360, Microsoft hired outside designers to improve the visual appeal of their next generation console. More recently they hired "GUI Guru" Bill Buxton http://news.zdnet.com/2100-3513_22-6001234.html to polish up their software interfaces.

All that makes it seem a little odd that they would target one of the most popular skins on the 'net for removal.

Comments
on Dec 21, 2005
on Dec 21, 2005
More likely than not, Kol's was targetted due to a simple word-search for 'vista'.  Others may simply have been overlooked due to name choice, but when/if found may suffer a similar fate....
on Dec 21, 2005
I think this topic has been discussed enough already!
on Dec 22, 2005
How true...
on Dec 22, 2005

Where have I heard this B4? If you want the skin email me at...

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx


 No need to rehash this topic. Kol's skin rox. MS shoulda hired him.

on Dec 22, 2005
And I don't remember kol wanting people to send his skin arround by mail.
on Dec 22, 2005
Always one.
on Dec 22, 2005
Yawn...
on Dec 22, 2005
Sorry if this was old news.

I saw the link in digg yesterday, and it was the first I'd heard of it.
Guess I haven't been visiting WC as often as I used to.

Oh, well. Happy Holidays to all, whatever way you celebrate it.

on Dec 22, 2005
I've been asking the same question.
on Dec 22, 2005
It really was a shame. Kol did a great job on that skin, but I'm sure we'll see some other great skins from him.

Posted via WinCustomize Browser/Stardock Central
on Dec 22, 2005
do we ever think we will see the skin come back should be the topic here i think???

people have been asking and asking for it.......

or are we going to have to wait til vista actually get released?
or is M$ goin to see how silly they're been and allow it back on the site?

peas
cityboy